When more than one individual claims the right to receive life insurance proceeds, the matter often escalates into a legal dispute. Conflicting claims can arise from outdated beneficiary designations, family conflicts, divorce, remarriage, or allegations of fraud or undue influence. In such cases, life insurance companies are placed in a difficult position and may not be able to determine the rightful beneficiary without court involvement.
Common Causes of Multiple Claims
Several scenarios commonly result in competing claims to life insurance benefits:
-
A former spouse is still named as the beneficiary, while a current spouse or children assert a superior claim
-
A policyholder changes the beneficiary near death, and family members question the validity of the change
-
Multiple forms exist with different designations, leading to confusion
-
An estate, trust, or will appears to contradict the policy documents
-
The named beneficiary has predeceased the insured, and no contingent beneficiary is listed
-
Children from different marriages submit competing claims
-
A handwritten or informal change of beneficiary lacks clarity or formality
These situations often create legal uncertainty that the insurer is not equipped to resolve unilaterally.
Role of the Insurance Company
When faced with competing claims, the insurance company has a legal duty to avoid double liability. Rather than attempt to resolve the dispute itself, the insurer typically initiates a legal process known as interpleader. In an interpleader action, the insurer deposits the policy proceeds with the court and asks to be dismissed from the case. The court then determines which claimant, if any, is legally entitled to the funds.
This process protects the insurer from paying the wrong party and places the burden of resolution on the claimants. Once the funds are deposited and the insurer is discharged, the litigation continues between the competing parties.
Legal Standards and Burdens of Proof
The resolution of multiple claims depends on several factors, including the clarity of the beneficiary designation, applicable state or federal law, and the credibility of any allegations surrounding the designation. Courts will typically rely on the most recent, valid beneficiary designation unless there is evidence that it was procured through fraud, coercion, or lack of capacity.
In some jurisdictions, equitable doctrines may allow a court to consider the policyholder’s intent, particularly if a divorce decree or settlement agreement directed certain beneficiary arrangements. However, federal law, such as ERISA, may override state rules and require strict adherence to the plan documents.
Each claimant bears the burden of proving entitlement. Evidence may include policy forms, court records, medical documentation, witness statements, or handwriting analysis.
Litigation Outcomes
Courts may award the full benefit to one claimant, divide the proceeds among several parties, or impose a constructive trust where one party holds the funds for the benefit of another. In some cases, settlements are reached before trial, particularly where the costs of litigation are high and the parties are willing to compromise.
The legal fees, time delays, and emotional costs of these disputes can be substantial. For that reason, early legal intervention and a clear litigation strategy are essential for any party involved in a multiple-claimant dispute.
Preventative Considerations
To reduce the risk of future conflict, policyholders should regularly review and update beneficiary designations, especially following major life events such as marriage, divorce, or the birth of a child. Beneficiaries should also be informed of their status and the existence of the policy. Clear documentation and formal updates are more effective than verbal promises or informal notes.
Conclusion
When multiple people claim life insurance benefits, the outcome is rarely straightforward. Courts must resolve factual and legal questions that go beyond the face of the policy. Understanding how these disputes are handled, what evidence matters, and which laws apply is critical for any party involved in a contested claim. In these situations, legal proceedings are often unavoidable and necessary to determine the proper recipient of the policy proceeds. To learn more about what happens when multiple people claim life insurance visit The Lassen Law Firm website.
